"How would you like that cooked?" trips up more people than it should. There is no wrong answer, but knowing the lingo means you get the burger you actually wanted instead of guessing. Here is the plain version.
The doneness ladder
- Medium-rare: warm red center, very juicy, soft. The most tender option.
- Medium: warm pink center, juicy, with a little more firmness. A popular middle ground.
- Medium-well: just a hint of pink, mostly cooked through, still juicy if it is good beef.
- Well-done: no pink, fully cooked through. Firmer, and the one to choose if pink is not your thing.
Why burgers are different from steak
With a steak, bacteria mostly live on the outside, so a hot sear makes a rare steak safe. Ground beef is a different story: grinding mixes the surface all the way through the patty, so there is no "outside" to sear clean. That is why food-safety guidance (the USDA) recommends ground beef be cooked to an internal 160°F, which lands around well-done. It is also why some kitchens will only cook a burger to a minimum temperature, and others will cook to your preference if you ask.
How to order what you want
Just say your preference out loud: "medium, please." If you like a little pink, ask whether the kitchen cooks burgers to temperature. If they cook everything through, medium-well is your friend, it is the juiciest a fully-cooked burger gets. And if you are not sure, ask the server how the chef recommends it. They cook it all day; they have an opinion worth hearing.
However you take it, the goal is the same: a burger you are happy with. Order it the way you actually like it, not the way you think you are supposed to.
← Back to the journal